What happens when the voices of LGBT+ people are heard in the Catholic church
Press release from the Catholic pastoral reality LGBT+ Catholics Westminster Pastoral Council* (UK), released on 8 May 2026 by LGBT+ Catholics Westminster, in response to the final report of the Study Group no. 9 of the Synod on synodality on “Theological criteria and synodal methodologies for the shared discernment of emerging doctrinal, pastoral and ethical issuesi". Freely translated by the volunteers of the Gionata Project
.
«The final report of the Study group N. 9 Of the Synod it far exceeded our expectations, because it clearly shows that the contributions sent by us and other European LGBT+ Catholic networks have left their mark", states the LGBT+ Catholics Westminster Pastoral Council of London.
The study group no. 9 is one of the ten groups established by Pope Francis to explore some concrete issues that emerged from the World Synod on the synodality of the Catholic Church, which took place between 2021 and 2024. In its report the group specifies: «we are presenting a simple, provisional and future-oriented summary of the work carried out so far, to be explored in depth through dialogue and to be verified in practice. It is not our job to address individual issues definitively. This Studio Group has neither the competence nor the necessary authorization to do so."
"The document, despite being written in the formal and academic language of theologians, represents a firm, clear and radical reaffirmation of the principles of the Second Vatican Council", declared Joe Stanley, of LGBT+ Catholics Westminster.
Martin Pendergast, also of LGBT+ Catholics Westminster, added: «This document, although not an official Vatican doctrinal statement, is surprisingly honest in recognizing what it calls “the inadequacy of our current categories and operational paradigms”. The text also speaks of "a persistent resistance (...) to change our habitual mental and behavioral habits".
The report decisively pushes the Catholic Church to overcome a rigid, top-down, imperious model, to instead rediscover the church as the People of God as a whole: a community of believers on a journey, called to discern God's will through the Holy Spirit, present in each of us, as we live the Gospel within concrete historical and cultural contexts.
The document replaces the idea of authority understood as "applicative logic", that is, as a power that establishes the teaching of the Catholic Church starting from presumed general principles, without considering the impact of that teaching on people's lives, with the idea of authority as a service.
We appreciate the Sudio Group's willingness to change the previous title, moving from "controversial" issues to "emerging" issues. It is a change that helps to move away from an approach centered on "problem solving" and instead opens up to a more relational dialogue, as the Catholic Church seeks to walk together with all its people. We also welcome the statement that this terminological shift "is not just superficial, but expresses a reformulation proposal linked to a paradigm shift."
The document often recalls parrhesia, that is, frank and free speech, when addressing the concerns of those who are considered "outside the game" or "outside the box": among them LGBTQ+ people, divorced and civilly remarried people, people who suffer discrimination, victims of abuse and injustice, and others. However, this positive aspect is weakened by the constant use of the more ideological expression "same-sex attraction", "attraction towards people of the same sex", while the original Italian version seems to simply refer to "homosexual believers".
A good example of the report's frankness is the recognition of the problems caused by the Courage group's approach, which, by pushing for so-called "reparative therapies", has had the effect of separating faith and sexuality rather than integrating them. This recalls the introduction to the document Pastoral Care of Homosexual People (Pastoral care of homosexual persons), authorized in 1979 By the catholic bishops of England and Wales.
Likewise, we welcome the inclusion of two strong testimonies from gay men, from Portugal and from the United States, who tell how they were able to integrate faith and sexuality by living as same-sex married couples.
We also welcome the fact that the report highlights the principle of "pastoralism", overcoming the rigid application of ideological-theological theories to human situations. The document instead valorises the lived experience of believers, read in the light of the Gospel and the discernment of the developments of the human and social sciences, as a source for renewing operational practices within a synodal Catholic church.
*The Westminster LGBT+ Catholic Pastoral Council (LGBT+ Catholics Westminster Pastoral Council) is appointed by the catholic Archdiocese Of Westminster (London, great britain) to: maintain relations with the Archdiocese of westminster on matters of pastoral care concerning lGBT+ Catholic people, their parents and their families; to identify the pastoral and sacramental needs of lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans catholic people, their parents and their families; to participate in the masses of The second and fourth sunday of the month, at 5.30 Pm, at the Church of the Immaculate Conception on Farm Street (London), and take care of the planning and organization of faith growth activities aimed at lGBT+ catholic Communities;
Original text: A response from the LGBT+ Catholics Westminster Pastoral Council to the Vatican's Synodal Study Group 9's Final Report (pdf file)

