Feminist theology. Reflecting with the Tomassone Pastora on overcoming domain relations
Article by Giuseppina D'Urso published on Adista new signs n ° 17 of 11 May 2019, pp.6-7
Letizia Tomassone is a pastora of the Valdese church in Florence. Consecrated in 1984, he had achieved the year before his degree in theology from the Valdese Faculty of Theology in Rome. Later he gets the Deoat (Master) in systematic theology at the Institut Protestant de Théologie de Montpellier (France).
From 2006 to 2012 he is vice -president of the Federation of Evangelical Churches in Italy. In 2010 he received the assignment of teaching and coordination of the courses of "Feminist and gender studies" always at the aforementioned Faculty, also dealing with studies of queer theology.
You would like to introduce yourself briefly
I grew up in post-1968 Piedmont, where I experienced both its bright and violent tails. I later attended university in Rome, participating in the '77 movement, becoming a feminist and frequenting the collectives of the Consiglio Vecchio. My studies at classical high school allowed me to access the Waldensian Faculty of Theology in Rome with a good level of Greek. Where I absorbed dialectical theology (Barth, Bonhoeffer) and the historical-critical approach to the Scriptures. Together with other students we read (in English) the early texts of feminist theologians such as Mary Daly.
The involvement in groups and conferences of young Europeans, such as the MCS (Christian student movement), was truly formative: I remember the adventurous trips to East Berlin and Ireland divided by the civil war. At the end of my studies in Rome I obtained a master's degree in Montpellier in France, where I encountered the thought of divergent theologians such as P. Tillich or A. Gounelle and where I had my first experiences of a multicultural society, far from coming to Italy.
Being part of the second generation of pastors (only two women had preceded us), I was immediately involved in the thought of the feminist movement and women's theologies: we organized meetings and seminars on the words of faith, which we questioned, such as obedience, redemption , sacrifice, service. These were years of growth for an entire generation of women involved in the Church and in social transformations.
Where does the interest in queer theology come from?
I attended Agape for more than a decade before becoming its “director” in the 1990s, for five years. It was an absolute period in my life for the quality of human encounters and for the experience that nourished thoughts, all within categories in which being a woman constituted the difference. I was dating at that time “Diotima” adhering to the thought of difference.
This thought, and all the reflection on female trust and authority, gave me the categories to think about my role, relationships, relationship with God. With the philosophers of difference, who were friends, projects and life paths were born . Only after a long time did I partially distance myself, especially from an essentialist way of seeing identity. In fact, in the meantime I had encountered the LGBT world and queer thought, which reshuffled the categories with which I thought about the world and the relationships between genders. From a rigid separatism I moved to a fluid queer dimension.
What differences and which similarities known in the approach to theology between the reformed and Catholic areas?
One of the central issues is that of a natural theology, rooted in creation and therefore immutable, winning in the traditional Catholic field, and a historical theology practiced in the Protestant world, which allows you to conceive changes compared to identity, genres, sexual relationships such as a brought of history. In fact, it is difficult in both areas to act authentic and lasting transformations. However, the Protestant approach has made it possible to have women and LGBT people among worship ministers and has opened to the blessing of homo -affective couples.
The Catholic theologians, with whom I participate in the beautiful adventure of the coordination of Italian theologians (CTI), have developed a great biblical competence, and the dialogue between us is fruitful. Of course, at Catholic level, there is still a lot of thirst to know the ways in which women read biblical texts and the history of the Church. In the most important Italian Protestantism the commitment to rename the divine appears by leaving a hegemonic and violent masculine, and trying to express the female in God.
On the ecclesiological level, the commitment of Catholic women for access to the ordered ministry seems to follow the stages of the battle made two centuries ago by women in the Protestant churches, even if the obstacles are more rooted to overcome.
What does it mean to be a woman, pastora And theologian in a valdese church that has advanced positions against the role of women, gender identities and sexual guidelines?
A prophetic position remains: the body of woman expresses different relationships between women and men, the authoritative word of a woman remains an exception, feminist theologies still deal with gender justice and human rights of women. Therefore, a lot has been done and we are grateful to the pioneers of feminist theological studies in every field, but it is not enough. The idea is that theology and faith are within history, and that biblical text is also a historical text.
So the responsibility for the interpretation in the face of the challenges of the present plays a fundamental role. Because this happens it is necessary that the question given by the word, in dialogue with the life of people, remains vital in the Church. An American Latin theologian states that women's life is also "sacred text", so for us also the life of the last and last is "sacred text", which questions us through the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
What can churches do to counter gender violence?
It is necessary to listen to the voices of women, not to speak for them, a danger lurking in unequal relationships of power and assistance. Women will tell what it means to not be believed, nor supported by families and other women. It is a question of overcoming the idea that love is based on the endurance and sacrifice of desire. Gender violence also develops towards homosexual and transsexual people, violence both physical and based on hatred speeches and prejudices that feed the contempt for subjects considered deviant. The churches must supervise their speaking, in order not to feed the language of contempt.
Listen and put the stories of the victims back to the center. It is important that the operators and pastoral workers are trained, that at the academic level the biblical texts that justify violence and subordination of gender are examined. This is the pivot of my teaching in the faculty of theology, aimed at restoring dignity to abject subjects and dismantling theological or biblical justifications of domain relationships. If people can make their voices heard, they are able to transform the churches and to ask them in front of the Gospel precisely to the heart of the most urgent issues of the present.
As a Pastora, what do you think of celibacy in the Catholic priesthood?
It can be a choice of life, but I believe that the person who exercises a ministry must live the wealth and difficulties of a love relationship in pairs. In this way he acquires thickness and knowledge of fundamental stages in the existence of those who turn to her, to him. One of the problems of women in churches was the finding of the curators of souls only males and unable to mediate between dogmas and life. Furthermore, becoming parents is such a rich experience that I find cruel to deprive people of people according to the role. It is clear that the imposition of celibacy in the Catholic field goes hand in hand with the avoidance of sexuality.
Attention must be paid to this, because sexuality is a gift of God, a way of being in relation between human beings with bodies, a source of joy and enjoyment. It is also a risky scope, in which subjugated relationships of power and relationships can be developed, when desire is not respected. Therefore the imposition of celibacy to priests tries to avoid one of the fundamental nodes of human relationships, impoverishing and stiffening them.
When is the collaboration with the coordination of Italian theologians born?
They are one of the founders of coordination, for a long time the only Protestant (today others have associated). I participated in the first national conference in the Capitol. But there were ecumenical relationships between theologian women before the CTI was born: we collaborated, looking for opportunities for exchanges and mutual insights, with cross invitations to conferences, as at the Women's Studies course that for about fifteen years we have carried out as Protestant women at the faculty Valdese of Rome.
Since 2010, a course of "feminist and gender studies" was established, of which I am in charge, which forms the future shepherds. The CTI gave a push to Italian publications and Italian scholars, and I also participated by publishing books important for me, one on Mary Daly, and another, the result of a conference in dialogue with Muslim and Jewish women, on the figure of Agar.
* Giuseppina D'Urso is a voluntary association "La Tenda di Gionata"And ofPax Christi Italia.

