Theology for unwanted people. Reclaim your place in the Catholic church
Text by Daniel C. Tillson*, taken from the book Theology for the Unwanted. Reclaiming Your Place in God's Church (Theology for Unwanted People. Taking Back Your Place in God's Church) published by Paulist Press (United States), 2025. Freely translated by Project Jonathan volunteers.
The author of this text asks himself what do you do when the Catholic Church makes you understand that it would be better if you were different? Is theology just to explain to you why you're wrong, or can it help you breathe, heal, and put the pieces back together? What if the problem wasn't finding a place in the Catholic Church, but stopping thinking that someone could take it away from you?
There is so much to be proud of as Catholics. Yet there are many days when I feel unwanted. Maybe you happen to feel the same thing. If so, I want to tell you right now: you are not alone. On average, every month, several other Catholics write to me to open up and tell me about struggles that they have kept locked inside for years. And rightly so. I know that pain too.
I continue to deeply love my faith, its language, its gestures, the way it taught me to look at God and the world. But it took me at least fifteen years before I was able to calmly say that being a gay person is a gift from God. I'm just an LGBT Catholic who seeks God as best he can, sharing what he experiences and what he discovers along the way. One thing, however, I know for sure: I am Catholic, without reservations. Although more than a few people smiled skeptically when I said it.
If you have been hurt, allow yourself to pause for a moment. You don't have to prove anything to anyone, or understand everything right away. There is an essential truth I want to deliver to you: you are a vital part of this family. The Church is not complete without you. For this reason it is the responsibility of the entire Catholic community to do better, to commit more, so that you can truly feel at home.
Many people, even with good intentions, disagree. They often do it out of fear, for fear that things will become complicated. He's human. As human beings we prefer an orderly religion, which has already solved everything, which does not ask too many questions and which is a stable rock when life is in a storm. My invitation goes to them too: to rediscover the depth of Catholic theology, to return to questioning what it really means to encounter God in the Eucharist and to let ourselves be provoked by two thousand years of thought that remind us of something simple and shocking at the same time: God not only loves, God is love.
Catholicity is surprising in its breadth. The Eucharist is celebrated every day, in the most diverse languages, from Syria to Mexico. We are not uniform, yet we are united. The Catholic Church has gone through enormous changes, yet remains deeply rooted in a truth that no one possesses, but within which we are all called to live. I believe that is precisely what makes it alive.
In some countries, especially those marked by a strong religious plurality or by very present Protestant traditions, such as the United States, Catholic theology has often been transmitted above all as a discipline. It's not like this everywhere, but if you're reading this book maybe you recognize that feeling. Furthermore, in English-speaking contexts, anti-Catholicism has pushed many faithful to band together as a family to survive. That connection was important, but not without consequences.
Every family knows wounds and successes. The problem arises when we confuse discipline with faith formation. We often only realize this when we encounter the Catholic Church in another culture and are surprised: "But is it really the same Church?". In the United States, that discipline has helped bring many people together, but for too many others it has become suffocating.
When a young lGBT+ catholic Adult tells me that he is left homeless or is no longer invited by his parents, the words of jesus resonate within Me: «Vthey will expel from the synagogues; Indeed, the hour is coming when whoever kills you will believe he is offering worship to God." (John 16.2). Not everyone has such dramatic experiences, but almost all of us, sooner or later, have been discarded by someone: a friend, a family member, a community.
How then can we find our place in the Catholic Church and, perhaps one day, heal these broken relationships? Should we just throw away the rules? No. For me the answers came through a deep dive into Catholic theology and prayer. The tools are already there.
An expert in canon law might tell you that sin is an offense against the truth. A moral theologian, however, would say that sin is failing to love as God created us. Because God is love. This is why in this book we will move above all within moral theology: the one that explores love for God, for people and for everything that God has created in his image.
Even chastity, an important virtue in love, has often been reduced to a list of rules. Thus it loses credibility and beauty. Seen only from a disciplinary point of view, it seems like control. But read theologically, it speaks of desiring the good of the other person, of not wanting to possess them. Chastity then becomes a language of love, capable of healing relationships marked by control and fear.
I remember a confession that profoundly marked my journey. An Italian priest, moral theologian and bioethicist, told me words that I have never forgotten: confession is not a tribunal, but an encounter with a doctor who heals. My wounds, he told me, had nothing to do with my orientation, but with the struggle to love myself as I was created. When we stop loving ourselves, then we struggle to love God and others. That's where we start to sin.
As a child I experienced confession as a laundry of the soul: you went in dirty and came out clean. It wasn't wrong, but it was incomplete. Today I know that it is much more: it is letting God transform me with his mercy, so that I can become more and more like him, Him who is the source and fulfillment of all authentic love.
In my book Theology for the Unwanted. Reclaiming Your Place in God's Church (2025) I also want to reflect on the rejection experienced by Jesus himself, on how he responded with love and truth to those who opposed him, «so that the word written in their law might be fulfilled» (John 15.25), and how he sought out unwanted people in places of prayer, transforming them into missionaries. In two thousand years, certain dynamics have not changed. This is why the theology of the Church continues to speak to the present.
(…) Catholic moral theology was born for an imperfect world and helps to seek the possible good in concrete situations. More and more people experience conditions that seem irreconcilable with Catholic law. Yet, if someone wishes to meet Jesus Christ, our task is to accompany him.
As professor mauro bianchi Reminds Us, moral theology is not a list of prohibitions, but a complex tool for learning to concretely imitate the love of Jesus, without reducing morality to a sequence of prohibitions. this Is the path we will try to explore together.
If your pain arises from other reasons, I still hope this book can help you. It is an invitation to follow Christ in all the complexities that make you exactly who you are. However messy life may seem to you, the Church is perfectly capable of accompanying you right where you are. This is why our parishes have soup kitchens, diaper drives, solidarity wardrobes, listening spaces for those who are alone, prison visits and much more. These ministries are signs of the Holy Spirit working to sanctify the people, uniting them with the suffering of the world, as Jesus did.
In part, the experiences of some LGBT people in the Catholic Church are reminiscent of those experienced by many black Catholics in the twentieth century. In many cities in the United States, especially in the South, a vibrant African-American Catholic culture still exists. Music, prayer, liturgy and lifestyle seemed foreign to many bishops of the time. The tensions of the civil rights movement of the 1960s only increased divisions.
Then came Sister Thea Bowman (1937–1990), a Franciscan nun of Perpetual Adoration, who spoke prophetically about how her identities were a gift to the Church. I'm sure many Catholic leaders of his time were confused: "What gifts? Why are you so different from us?" Yet, the experiences of oppression experienced by the Black Catholic community have profoundly enriched theology.
Shortly before her death, Sister Thea Bowman spoke to Catholic bishops about her experience of feeling unwanted in the Church because of her skin color. She said that she would not leave any part of her identity on the doorstep and that, when looking at images of the Catholic Church around the world, many of the people depicted looked like her (Bowman 1989). Today Thea Bowman is a candidate for the honors of the altars.
Likewise, I look forward to the day when the Catholic Church also recognizes you, who are reading this, for the unique gifts and talents you bring to this community. And, like Thea Bowman, I am full of hope.
If you feel unwanted or struggling with your faith, I invite you to read this book. It is a book of hope, written to help you recognize your place of love in the heart of the Church, exactly as you are. I hope you too can find your own answers through a deep dive into Catholic theology.
Original text: Theology for the Unwanted: Background there is so much to be proud of as a Catholic.


