A che serve la pastorale LGBTQ? A ricordare alle persone che sono amate da Dio
ISH rUIZ* Article Published on the outreach website (USA) On july 8, 2025, freely translated by Luigi and Valeria de La Tenda di Gionata
In the spring of 2018 I participated in a meeting of young adults LGBTQ at the church of the Santissima Redentore in Castro, the so -called gay neighborhood in San Francisco (United States). The guidance of the meeting proposed a reflection on the history of the fall of Adam and Eva in the genesis, and this session had a significant impact on the way I carry out my service with LGBTQ people.
The central question he asked was: "What was Eva's original sin?".
Several young adults proposed the usual answers: "Disobling to God" and "greed". I, who I was a teacher of Sacra Scripture of first higher for several years and who at the time was completing a doctorate in theology, I strongly supported the thesis of "pride".
The guide agreed that these were all elements of the fall, but added that there is a component of the original sin, often neglected, which is more important than those mentioned.
He explained that, in order for the snake to try Eva with disobedience, greed or pride, he had to instill a perverse idea in his mind: that Eva was not going well as it was ... had to be more; He had to do it firsthand and take the situation in his hand to "be like God" or to be closer to God.
This means that Eva (and, following, adam) Has chosen to give up confidence in the Creator (catechism of The Catholic church, N. 397) and to do something to earn a place closer to God.
The temptation of pride, lust, avidity or any other capital sin derives from this belief of not being sufficiently good as we are. This lack of awareness of our intrinsic goodness (or "original holiness", according to CCC, n. 375) pushes us to try to fill with sin what we perceive as a condition of emptiness and lack.
Knowing this, the snake had to somehow make Eva forget that it was made to imago Dei (image of God), in a wonderful and extraordinary way, and which was already in perfect communion with God in the garden of Eden. Eva let himself be convinced by the idea of being insufficient in some way. Forget to be imago Dei it was the cause before his sin.
The Church teaches that original sin refers to the first act of humanity to disobey god And not to trust in his goodness, which broke the original harmony of the order created and has injured human nature as a whole, making it prone to distrust and alienation, with the consequence of sin.
According to the guide of the meeting, the first disobedience was caused by the lack of recognition of our original holiness.
This interpretation of the history of Genesis seemed extremely important to me, because it guides the way we have to work with LGBTQ people.
There are tight ties between the concept of original sin and sexual morality throughout our Christian tradition. It is known that Sant'Agostino D'Ippona had stated that original sin is transmitted through the sexual act, thus connecting sin to sexual desire, which led to the persistent theological insistence on sexual morality.
This heritage continues today, given that the Catholic hierarchy often focuses disproportionately on issues of sexuality in moral discourse.
The LGBTQ pastoral care is often focused exclusively on efforts to make LGBTQ people abstain from homosexual acts or therapies for gender affirmation. Some service experiences, such as Courage, for example, help LGBTQ people to take a path to sexual abstinence.
Other groups, when they propose retreats or conferences for LGBTQ people, often feel asking for diocesan managers if the importance of the doctrine of the Church on sexual morality will be underlined in their meetings.
In my experience of organizing LGBTQ retreats, conferences and other pastoral events, I constantly feel like asking if the Catholic doctrine on sexual morality will be treated in the encounter. Many exponents of the ecclesiastical hierarchy want to be sure that we are taking every opportunity to convince the participants of the immorality of homosexual acts or of gender affirmation paths.
Obviously, I am not asked to reiterate the doctrine relating to sexual morality in any of the pastoral encounters for heterosexual people. There is a problematic, disproportionate and (in my opinion) discriminatory obsession for the sexual acts of LGBTQ people.
Perhaps this is why, in an interview in which she felt obliged to take a decisive position on issues of sexual morality (relating to both homosexual and heterosexual acts), Pope Francis has known: "It is not necessary to always speak of these themes".
I agree with Pope Francis because, regardless of ethical opinions on sexual morality, there is a more basic question that should be taken into consideration when we engage in this pastoral care: like Eva, to LGBTQ people it was made to forget that we are made in the image of God in a wonderful and extraordinary way, and that God loves us as we are.
Unfortunately, our Church and our society have often strengthened this amnesia during our path of growth and maturation. The disproportionate insistence on respect for sexual morality and even the use of words such as "intrinsically disordered", as far as moved by good intentions, decrease our self -esteem by reducing our identity exclusively to the mechanics of a sexual act.
The task of those who deal with pastoral care with LGBTQ people is to fight this amnesia and remember that we are good and worthy of respect and dignity. This is the basic truth of our existence.
It is ironic the fact that lGBTQ Catholics are often very prepared on the doctrine of the church's Sexual morality, as i experienced in my ministry with lGBTQ People for over a decade. After all, we Were - so to Speak - beaten on the head with this doctrine since we reached sexual maturity.
LGBTQ people don't need to know more about sexual morality. We need spaces where you can pray, serve, create communion and reaffirm our fundamental reality as people made in theimago Dei. A pastoral that deals with these things can create a context where LGBTQ people can trust in the goodness of God.
When we reorient LGBTQ pastoral to the recognition of the dignity and adequacy of each person, we make room for the grace of God that flows into our lives and discover a beautiful truth: LGBTQ people are blessed and loved by God.
The fruit of the blessing of God fills our community. Thanks to this divine love, our LGBTQ community - including our community of believing LGBTQ people - is vibrant, full of energy, creative, oriented to justice and family. We take care of each other and defend ourselves with each other. We build family ties through our "election families" and we try to promote a world in which everyone is free.
This is what means to be LGBTQ and it is the reason why I firmly believe that LGBTQ people offer important gifts to the Catholic Church. Remember the words of Jesus: "From their fruits you will recognize them" (Mt 7:16).
The Pastoral LGBTQ should be a dedicated space where we can discern the will of God in our life and where we can share our gifts with the Church.
Although the sexual doctrine of the Church offers important food for thought on our identity, the first step to reaffirm our dignity of beings created in theimago Dei it is to counteract the original sin that makes us forget that we are good and that God loves us as we are.
*ISH RUIZ is post-dictate scholarship in studies on the doctrine of the Catholic Church at the Candler School of Theology of Hematory University in Atlanta. Former teacher of high school cattolica, he achieved a doctorate of research at the Graduate Theological Union of Berkeley, California.
Original text: LGBTQ ministry exists to remind people that they are love by God

