What paths with transgender people in the Catholic Church? "
Intervention by the journalist Luciano Moia* held at the meeting "Corner Stones"(Florence, April 5, 2025)
Towards transgender people, the attitude of the Church is still pervaded by shyness and contradictions. The pastoral welcome is episodic and fragmentary almost everywhere, and even when there is a formal opening then specifically we remain in the vague.
We struggle to question ourselves as a Christian community about the need to deepen experiences, focus on perspectives, increase knowledge without prejudice and without pre -packaged recipes. In reality, when we talk about sexual orientation and, above all, of gender identities, clichés prevail, stereotypes. Difficult to find an educator, but also a priest who has clear ideas.
Yet, these are joints that it is now urgent to face from a cultural, educational and pastoral point of view, but also by enhancing the point of view of believing LGBT people who live too often the uncertainties and silences of the Church as disappointment and, sometimes, as a personal defeat.
Because a believing community unable to offer encouraging prospects and often also to express well-founded, aware and scientifically consistent considerations on the many problems related to "difficult" sexuality, or in any case unconventional, lived by these people, is a community that risks self-confirmed in a besieged stronghold, where misunderstandings and prejudices, bans and alarmisms win.
But, while we are getting on the defensive, unable to listen, frightened by the need to ask ourselves, uncertain about the ways to be proactive in an original way, evangelically and humanly captivating, life flows elsewhere.
And we remain on the defensive, unable to formulate truly convincing and original hypotheses, unable to face the anthropological and cultural questions of our day. Inevitable that then the pastoral is also ends to adapt to an atmosphere of uncertainty, which too often hides indifference, if not suspicious.
Yet, in recent years, let's say starting from the synodal season wanted by pope Francis (2013-2016) the Church has attempted on various occasions to leave the walls of suspicion and to ask some questions.
How to spread among transgender people the seeds of good of understanding, benevolence, welcome and mercy? how to Understand and welcome? someone Still supports the need for a "non -specific" Pastoral welcome, neutral way, perhaps a little detached, without getting too involved.
But for people already marked by a feeling of marginality if not abandoned, a generic pastoral can be enough that does not take into account what life has left in the soul of these women and these men forced to fight with an uncertain identity, however tiring? Why then not encourage a more conscious, meditated and not episodic pastoral?
A pastoral care capable of looking in the face, without false purists, the choices of these people - who then "choices" are not, because no one "chooses" one's sexual orientation - and offer proposals of Christian life also capable of reflecting on a non -binary reading of sexuality as an integral part of the person and his choices of faith?
Difficult, of course. Also because it is a field of investigation still little or at all frequented by theology. While on homosexuality there are courageous and alternative texts - but still of great cultural thickness such as that of Aristide Fumagalli (Possible love. Homosexual and moral people christian, Publishing citadel) but not only - on the transgender world we are still waiting for equally important insights.
Still, it is a challenge that the christian world can no longer postpone. reflecting, Discussing, deepening, comparing the dictation of reality with the statements of the standard does not mean denying, nor contradicts, nor pretending to rewrite what seemed to be established forever.
It only means observing reality, trying to understand it, not fear of asking even the most uncomfortable questions in view of the authentic and integral good of people. So, without fear, let's ask ourselves the most demanding question: in addition to the male and female there is something else?
How can we go into such a nebulae human frontier, in which we sometimes cannot distinguish the traits? How to check if the schemes that we usually appeal to tell the beauty and mystery of sexuality are truly exhaustive for all real, concrete situations, those we meet in everyday life? That's why, in addition to charity, it serves the will to understand and ability to question themselves.
Many questions still to be explored. Starting with the most demanding one: the one expressed towards transsexuals from the Church, from our communities, by the self -styled Christians has so far been an attitude of authentic and real Christian mercy?
The pontificate of Pope Francis was from this point of view a beneficial shock. There is no need to retrace here the turning point impressed by the many interventions on the welcome due to "Todos, Todos, Todos", none excluded, on the existential suburbs, on the need for our communities to be transformed into "customs places".
But it is certain that the words from n.250 of Amoris laetitia, where Francesco says among other things that every person "regardless of his sexual orientation" must be welcomed with dignity and respect, they cannot leave indifferent. It is as if he told us that the different guidelines exist, they must not be judged, nor demonized because every heterosexual, homosexual or transsexual person has first of all has a dignity that derives from being the daughter or son of God.
The help that the Church must ensure to those who manifest "the homosexual tendency" and therefore - if the phrase expressed shortly before - any other trend is made, should not be commensurate with the alleged ethical quality of the tendency itself.
It is no coincidence that we speak of "respectful accompaniment" which means an accompaniment offered without the will to interfere, without objectives to change the profile of that orientation more or less explicitly.
But the welcome that must be reserved for each person, "regardless of their sexual orientation" implies at least two other considerations, which are also two powerful stresses to make a courageous cultural and pastoral leap.
It is necessary to consider the possibility that the orientation can also translate into an inner malaise, into a difficulty in harmonizing one's biological sexuality with one's own gender identity. And, at the same time, it is essential to understand how to build a pastoral proposal capable of integrating with the complexities deriving from "non -binary" but equally and deeply human and real identities and identities.
It is the Pope himself who asks us, inviting to ensure "a respectful accompaniment". But to respect it is necessary to know. To know, it is necessary to have the humility to form and grow in terms of awareness.
Now the belief according to which sexual orientation does not follow identical patterns for everyone seems to be widely majority, does not respect our binary definition claim.
That's why it is necessary to continue reflecting together, without fears and without predetermined patterns, aware that the road is still long. We must overcome some uncertainties that appeared on the topic in the last part of the pontificate of Pope Francis - starting with what we read in Infinite dignitas speaking of gender and transsexuality, where issues are synthesized in an almost trivializing way - and above all we have to understand what Leone XIV's attitude will be.
The great question of human dignity linked to sexual identity can no longer be addressed with blows of prohibitions and "judgments" of the magisterium, but with choices of pastoral welcome nourished by sympathy, courage and concreteness. Let's not get tired of repeating it and telling it.
*Luciano Moia has been a journalist to take place where, for over twenty years, he has been the editor -in -chief of the monthly supplement dedicated to the "Noi Famiglia & Vita" family. He is also the author of about fifteen books, among the best known are "Church and homosexuality" (2020) and "children of a minor God? Transgender people and their dignity" (2022), in which he faces with rigor and humanity ethical, family and pastoral issues.

